Showing posts with label golf business. Show all posts
Showing posts with label golf business. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 3, 2018

Who Are Really the Best Teachers?

I was watching the golf tournament last weekend and kept seeing ads from Revolution Golf and the Golf Channel promoting how great their golf instructors are and it reminded me of a recent conversation I had.

In that discussion about golf instruction  it was pointed out to me that golf instruction is almost completely subjective.  All about marketing and taking peoples word for how good they are and how good their theories and methods are.

SUBJECTIVE EVIDENCE is evidence that you cannot evaluate -- you have to simply accept what the person says or reject it.

OBJECTIVE EVIDENCE is evidence you can examine and evaluate for yourself.

My friend, Judge Tinker, frequently talks about how few people are interested in taking golf lessons and how few golfers actually take them. I think there may be a correlation between that and SUBJECTIVE EVIDENCE.  Today's consumers tends to be very cynical so simply trying to market to them by saying trust me, I am better or trust me, I can help you isn't going to work with most people.

In the past golf professionals were held in much higher esteem than they seem to be today so what worked in the past may not work as well today especially with younger people.

With verifiable data would golfers tend to trust you more?


Is it possible that more people would be prone to take lessons if there was OBJECTIVE EVIDENCE to prove how good someone and their methods are?  With today's technology it seems to be very doable. It be a simple matter of using technology to establish a baseline for each student. Prior to the first lesson simply chart club head speed, smash factor, center line variance, carry distance etc. After 4 lessons do the readings again and compare them to the baseline readings. That would give objective evidence of how much a teacher can actually improve his or her students in 4 lessons. No debate, no simply proclaiming that you help everybody, it would just recording the facts.

I know that those people that are successful today are not interested in seeing anything change and I don't blame them.   It is like the old saying, “If it ain't broke don't fix it,” but for the younger teachers coming up and trying to get themselves established and build a clientele I would think that they would embrace the idea of objective evidence. I think it might have a very positive effect on the golfing public if someone can say here is the evidence that, x percent of the time my students improve by X percentage with only 1,2,3,4 lessons etc.

Can you imagine a Top 100 List based on OBJECTIVE EVIDENCE?  Might be interesting.


Friday, September 22, 2017

Science and Golf Instruction

I am definitely old school but I have always been fascinated by advances in science and technology that have the possibility to help me as a person or as a golf professional.  That is why I got into computers before they had hard drives and video when they were battling between VHS and Betamax.  It is also why I started studying neuroscience as it applies to how people learn.

I know many will not agree with what I am about to say and I understand that.  It is only my opinion, but I am fairly intelligent and have very accurate logic and BS filters.  Because of that I have come to this conclusion.

My Conclusion


Science and technology seems to have hijacked golf instruction.  Because of things like Doppler radar, 3-D, Biomechanics, etc. we have turned golf instruction into numbers, minute positions and body parts.

As a friend of mine, Mike Rubino, who is an attorney and avid student of the game said, “The scientist and so called experts of today have invented a whole new golf lexicon and proclaim that without a complete understanding of their jargon you can't possibly teach or learn golf correctly.”
Sadly even the scientist and PhD’s don’t agree with each other.  The major benefit of all this seems to be in selling seminars and certifications so golf professionals can learn how to use the new jargon and terms that have been invented.

When I read about this and listen to the comments a term comes to mind that best describes it.  The definition follows:

“Mental Masturbation: Pleasurable but unproductive mental activity; at least in the short-term. Sometimes people use a tool, language, or technique because it has ideas that stimulate or entertain their mind. It might not be "better", but one likes it because of the stimulation or challenge it provides.”

Having been in the business for a long time now I have seen these “going to revolutionize golf instruction” come and go on a regular basis always to be replaced by the next “great breakthrough” that doesn’t materialize.

When I got into the business many years ago it was all about teaching people to PLAY golf.  Somewhere along the way technology transformed it into focusing only on the golf swing.  It is now all about numbers, positions, body parts and terminology.

The end result is that today only one golfer out of seventeen will even consider taking a lesson.

I know this will offend those that have spend a great deal of time and money on technology and getting certified but is this what we should consider progress?  You decide.


That is my view from the Golf Cave

Friday, September 15, 2017

The Golf Industry Has Shot Itself in the Foot

Recently I have been reading a research paper by a major university on the state of the golf industry and it seems that a lot of the challenges golf faces today are self-inflicted.

The Factors Contributing to Golf's Problems:

  • The over building of golf courses during the boom years of the 1990’s.
  • The building of longer, harder and more expensive golf courses.
  • The slow play created by longer, harder, real estate development type golf courses.
  • The building golf courses on speculation and not on socioeconomic demand.
  • The building of golf courses that never had a viable business plan and are now environmentally, economically, and socially unsustainable.
In other words, even without a recession the golf industry would still be in trouble because of the paradigm change that occurred in the 1990’s.

What we have today is a situation where almost 90 percent of the golf courses are public access and roughly 30 percent are financially healthy, about 30 percent are slightly profitable or close to breaking even, and around 30 percent that are likely go out of business.

What we do know:

  • We know there are about 4300 golf courses on the market for sale today. 
  • We know there are currently about 1600 golf courses operating under bankruptcy protection.
  • We know golf courses need to book about 64% of available tee-times to break even. 
  • We know 60% of the golf courses are booking 44% of their available tee-times.

The Good News:

Help is on the way.  A book will be released in the near future that will offer a smorgasbord of proven techniques for operating profitably and turning money losers into money makers.  It will also cover golf instruction from a standpoint the will make it of interest to both teaching professionals and golfer alike.  I have only had glimpses at the data but it is extremely impressive.  I can only imagine the time, effort and money that have been poured into this project.



Thursday, August 31, 2017

A Fresh Look At Why Golf Is Struggling

I recently came across an interesting article from the Wall Street Journal on Golf.  A little different perspective than what I am used to seeing.  I especially like the comments by Joe Beditz of the National Golf Foundation.

By Brandi Shaffer

A report by the National Golf Foundation shows that while the sport is attracting more new players than at any time since the early 2000s, few new golfers are sticking with the game. The NGF found that comfort and competence primarily drive retention, and puts the onus on golf properties to offer the facilities and programs that keep golfers interested in the long haul.

American golf is attracting more new players in the U.S. now than at any time since the early 2000s, but the National Golf Foundation’s annual participation report shows another decline in the number of people who played the game at least once in the last year, the Wall Street Journal reported.

These two contradictory trends may be the most telling indication of the state of the industry: Plenty of people are taking up the game for the first time, but very few of them are sticking with it. And according to the NGF, a leading research and consulting group, that is less an indictment of the game itself than of the operators of the country’s more than 15,000 courses, WSJ reported.

“Golf needs to be more beginner-friendly,” said NGF chief executive Joe Beditz. “It’s like we’re running a gas station. ‘Come or don’t come. Here’s the price.’”


Roughly 2.2 million Americans aged 6 and older played golf for the first time in 2015, according to the NGF, the most since 2002. That is up from a post-recession low of 1.5 million beginners in 2011. Yet the overall number of participants still fell to 24.1 million, a marginal drop from 24.7 million in 2014 and down from a peak of 30 million in 2005, WSJ reported.

The leak isn’t coming from the core of the industry: a group of nearly 20 million people who play golf regularly say in surveys they are likely to continue doing so. It’s coming from the people who never make it into that group, WSJ reported.

Nearly 90% of the people who left the game in 2015 never became regular golfers, which the NGF defines as playing at least eight times per year. Taken together, the numbers portray a business that is being handed new customers, through the sheer allure of the game, and which lacks either the ability or the interest to turn them into devoted regulars, WSJ reported.

In an interview last week, Tiger Woods echoed the NGF’s call for courses to be more welcoming to beginners. “How do you keep them still interested in it?” Tiger Woods said. “How do you keep it fun? That’s one of the things we’re running into right now with the game of golf. It’s just stagnant. We have people come into the game but they exit the game. There’s no sustainability.”

In what seems like annual obituaries written about golf, two factors often cited are time and money. But in its surveys of people who quit the game, the NGF found that what really drives retention are two factors less often discussed, WSJ reported.

One is comfort—how comfortable a beginner is both on the course and around other golfers—which is mostly a function of atmosphere. The assumption at most courses is that a person walking in is familiar with everything from the pre-round routine to the countless unspoken rules of etiquette. In fact, beginners understand little of it. People who quit often never get past feeling like an outsider in a club for insiders, WSJ reported.

The other factor is competence. Most beginners who don’t get hooked say they never felt “shot euphoria”—the thrill of the one great shot, however rare, that keeps even the most casual players coming back. By contrast, they almost surely felt the humiliation of hitting their first tee shot 10 feet while the starter watches on, WSJ reported.

Part of the problem is the way people are introduced to the game, typically through a relative or friend. New golfers are far more likely to keep playing if they start with a structured program such as Get Golf Ready, which offers five group lessons for as little as $99. The program covers everything from swing basics to etiquette, guides people onto the course and helps them find other beginners to play with. But Beditz said such programs aren’t marketed well enough, WSJ reported.

Another problem is that the typical golf course is not set up for beginners to ease their way in. It’s akin to a ski resort without a bunny hill or a swimming pool without a shallow end. There is the course: 18 holes, often designed with the avid player in mind. And there is the driving range and practice green: easy enough to futz around on but also boring. There is nothing in between, WSJ reported.

The incentives to make golf more fun should be strong enough. Aside from the rise in beginners, the NGF will report Tuesday that 37.4 million non-golfers are at least somewhat interested in playing golf now, based on broader sports participation surveys conducted by the Physical Activity Council. The question is how many of them will ever play golf regularly, WSJ reported.

“There has to be an embrace of these people, and it has to happen at the golf course. That’s our front door,” Beditz said. “All of the preaching by guys like me will do absolutely no good if 15,000 golf courses are not managed better.”


Maybe growing the game wouldn’t be so difficult if we focused on how to retain the people that are coming into the game already.