Thursday, April 27, 2017

A Different Take on Chipping and Pitching

A little different tip on chipping and pitching.  I keep seeing articles about your setup on short shots and chip shots, but for some reason, no one mentions that alignment for each shot is slightly different.  The length of the shot and how high or low you want the ball to fly is determined by your setup and alignment.

While ball position and lower body alignment may vary, the one constant is shoulder alignment.  Your shoulders should always be parallel to your target line on any shot whether you are hitting a driver or a putter.  NOT pointed at the target, but parallel to it.

Lower Body Open

The lower body – meaning the feet, legs, and hips - will be open or pointing left of the target in order to get yourself out of your own way.  The club needs to travel down the target line as long as possible and a square stance makes it much more difficult to accomplish that.

The single most important factor in developing a good short game is that you absolutely must learn to contact the ground in the same spot in your swing every time.  To accomplish this you simply need to stabilize your weight.  The low point in your swing arc is wherever your weight (body mass) is.  If you shift your weight the bottom of your arc moves constantly with your weight.  The odds of winning the lottery are better than the odds of getting your weight in the same spot every time if it is shifting.

One point that needs to be made at this time is watching and reading about how tour players do it is a waste of time unless you are already that good.  Tour players have extraordinary hand-eye coordination, touch, and feel so they can do things in their swing that would be problematic for the average golfer.

Keep the Weight on Your Left Foot

It is easier to just place the weight on the left side or left foot and keep it there throughout the swing.

Keep the club low to the ground as long as possible on the backswing and the follow through.  Never make any attempt to lift the club or forcibly cock the wrists unless hitting out of deep grass.  Keep the hands quiet.  Over active hands will result in fat and thin or skulled shots.

Another very important factor is to be able to have your hands in the same position at impact that you did at address.  The club head must never pass the hands until well after impact unless you are very talented with a high lob shot.  The chipping or pitching swing is made primarily with the hands, arms and shoulders.  Unless it a long pitch the lower body does not get involved.

How long the shot is determines how wide or narrow the stance and how open your body is.  For a chip shot your right foot is very close to your left foot and your lower body is very open.



For a pitch shot it is less pronounced.  The hands will generally be more forward on a chip, but the height of the ball flight will be determined by the loft of the club and the forward lean of the shaft.


 Choke Down

One final point that needs to be addressed is gripping down or “choking up” on the club.  The shorter the shot the more you choke up.  It is perfectly fine to grip all the way down to the bottom of the grip.  This enable you to be firmer and more aggressive because the shorter you make the club the shorter distance you will hit the ball.


Hubert Green who had 19 PGA Tour wins including 2 majors used to choke the sand wedge all the way down onto the steel and open the face so he could be firm and aggressive.  Never let the golf club slow down prior to impact.  Taking it back too far and slowing down prior to impact will cause the club head to pass the hands with the absolute certainty of a bad shot.

Practice with slightly different alignments until you find what is most comfortable for you.  I suggest practicing extensively with a sand wedge which is about 56 degrees.  By adjusting the shaft lean forward and backward you can learn to hit a variety of shots.  I am not a fan of using the lob wedge to chip or pitch with.  I agree with Barney Adams, the founder of Adams Golf, when his club designer told him they were going to design a 60 degree lob wedge he told them to stamp a skull and cross bone on it.

As you go from a full swing to a less than full swing to a chip the right foot gets closer and closer to the left and the hips open more and more.  Shoulders stay parallel to the line.
Once you have learned to develop a solid short game simply start taking a bigger and faster swing and gradually square your body alignment and you will have an excellent full swing.

The video below will show you how practicing the chip swing helps your full swing.


Tuesday, April 18, 2017

Note to My Younger Self On Teaching


The golf business in general and the golf instruction business in particular are much different today than when I got my start over 40 years ago.  That alone makes me Old School, but I can truthfully say that I have never stopped learning from and listening to the best and brightest in the business.  With what knowledge I have gained over my career I have reached some conclusions.

If I were a young person just starting out in golf instruction today here is what I would tell my younger self.

Take the time to study the great teachers of the past and learn everything you can about “how” they taught.  The “what” they taught is not as important as “how” they taught.  Also learn as much as you can about how people actually learn.   Learning is learning and it is the same for golf as anything else.  Also develop and polish your communication skills because no matter how much knowledge you gain it will be pointless if you can’t convey it to the student so that they can assimilate it and make use of it.

I would also advise him to be very selective with technology.  Much of what is out there today will suffer the same fate as the Polaroid Graph Check Sequence Camera and Sony Betamax even though it is being hyped as “The Answer” to revolutionizing how the game is taught. It is also very,very expensive so choose wisely.  There is new technology in the pipeline that will be more useful than some of what we have today so you need to keep your eyes and your mind open and be ready to embrace it.  The younger golfers coming into the game today have a much different attitude than the people of my generation and they want and expect technology.  They are not going to just take your word for things.  They want it verified by numbers that they can understand and relate to.

Their lifestyles are also very different and the vast majority doesn’t have time for or even want a series of one hour lessons followed by hours of practice.  That’s what the new customer wants so learn to adapt to it.

Final note to self:  If you are going to become successful today you will need to combine Old School simplicity, New School technology, great communications skills, and a healthy dose of brain compatible teaching knowledge.  If you combine of all that you will stand out from the competition and be well on your way.



Friday, April 7, 2017

The Masters Tournament Makes the Competitive Juices Flow Like No Other

The reason it is so difficult to predict a winner for the Masters Tournament is that no other event affects the players quite the same way.  You can hear it in their voice when they talk about the drive down the fabled Magnolia Lane.  The comments over and over about the emotions it stirs no matter how many times they have played there.

We are all aware of the fact that this would complete a career grand slam for Rory and elevating himself to the level of Gene Sarazen, Ben Hogan, Gary Player, Jack Nicklaus and Tiger Woods is a tremendous motivation.  We also know how good Sergio is playing and Lord knows Sergio wants it.
 
Bubba Watson also seems to rise to the occasion at the Masters and the course seems to suit his game. Can he win a third Green Jacket to go with his first two?
 
There are three players out there with some age and experience that you can’t rule out because they have tools necessary and could easily catch the Masters Magic.  They are Fred Couples, Lee Westwood and Phil Mickelson, especially since Phil has won it three times already. Experience is a big advantage in these weather conditions.

I personally believe that this has to be killing Tiger Woods.  He would be the prime candidate to get caught up in the “Masters Effect.”  Nobody has more motivation to embrace it than Tiger and he certainly has the history and memories to ignite it.  The most dominate player of his era is still in there somewhere and the Masters may be trying to pull it out again.

Jack Nicklaus was the perfect example of what I’m talking about.  I do realize that Nicklaus is one of the best to ever play the game, but he is exactly what I’m talking about.  In 1986 the Tournament Players Championship was played two weeks prior to the Masters and Nicklaus failed to make the cut.
The week prior to the TPC he withdrew after the first round.  Three weeks later he arrives in Augusta and came home to the magic of the event, Magnolia Lane, and the memories of his previous five wins.  The last win had been eleven years earlier in 1975.  On that Sunday the memories and the emotions grabbed him and propelled him to a 30 on the back nine for his 6th Masters and final major.

Every year we see the competitive juices start to flow in players that have a history with Augusta and this year will certainly be no different.  Strap yourself in and hang on for the ride.



That is it from the Golf Cave for this week.  Enjoy the Masters!

Thursday, March 30, 2017

Golf Instruction: A Shrink’s View of Golf Teaching

I think this is worth sharing from a student's standpoint of finding a good instructor and an instructor's standpoint of being educational.

Posted on December 17, 2014
Psychotherapy
(Reprinted from PGA MAGAZINE, 3/1/08)

A lot has been written by golf professionals about what amateurs need to do to improve, but we read little from amateurs about what PGA professionals need to do to become better instructors. As a psychotherapist, I’ve always been interested in how people change. So, when I’ve gone to see a golf instructor – and I’ve seen many – I pay close attention to what works and what doesn’t. And, it’s no surprise that, just as therapy varies widely in its effectiveness, so too does golf instruction. Much of it is bad; occasionally it’s good.

The problem with ineffective golf instruction, as with ineffective therapy, is that the recipient often blames himself or herself for a failure to improve. In each situation, the client needs help – sometimes desperately – and is willing to put him or herself into the care of a professional. Because of this dependency, a great deal of authority is conferred on the professional. The person seeking help is eager for approval and is usually not in a position to accurately judge his or her helper. Poor outcomes usually lead to demoralization and self – blame.

Since I’ve spent a fair amount of time as both a helper and a person seeking help, I’ve reached some conclusions about what makes the learning process work, conclusions that I think might be of value to both teaching professionals and the average golfer. But before I spell out what makes a good golf teacher, I want to add a caveat: most of my difficulties as a golfer have nothing to do with my instruction. I’ve had enough good instructors to know how to improve. But, like most amateurs, I don’t practice or play nearly enough. As a result, I’m a 16 handicap player with an eight handicap swing!

In my view, good golf teachers share with good therapists the following traits:


1) They listen to what the client/student wants from the session.

Too often, instructors want to teach what they know without first finding out what the student is really there for. The best teachers try to figure out if the student primarily wants a quick fix, an adjustment that will help him or her have a more enjoyable round that day, or a plan to reconstruct his or her swing over the long haul. There’s nothing wrong with going to a PGA professional to get a “tip” that temporarily corrects a swing flaw, even if that tip is really only a compensatory adjustment for a deeper problem. A good teacher will tailor the instruction to the agenda of the student.

For example, I was once was about to leave for a special golf outing, and was fighting a frustrating slice. I went to a teacher and explained the situation. He told me to significantly close my stance, almost as if I was setting up to hit a big hook. This tip enabled me to play several rounds on my trip from the fairway rather than the woods. In that instance, the teacher understood that I wasn’t going to work with him over time to correct my more fundamental problems.

Too often, a student seeks help for one particular thing, not intending to sign up for a major overhaul, and is told that the problem ultimately derives from several fundamental problems at the core of his or her swing, problems that can only be addressed by a series of lessons over time. Like therapists, golf teachers can be correct but not helpful.

2) They learn to speak the client’s language

Some students are left-brain thinkers who respond best when the teacher explains his or her suggestions intellectually, offering the student the theory guiding instruction. Other students learn best through visual demonstrations, either computer – aided, or modeled by the instructor. And still other students need to primarily feel the changes in their own bodies. While everyone hopes to eventually combine these three modalities, it is essential that the instructor quickly adapt his or her teaching style and drills to the idiosyncratic learning styles of the student.

A friend and I once took lessons from the same golf instructor. He was great with my friend because he gave a lot of technical instruction – which satisfied my friend’s thirst for mechanical details – but the identical instruction was frustrating to me because I work best when I have a clear visual image of the “correct” way to do something. For example, I would have gotten more benefit from watching my instructor illustrate the correct move, or by watching a professional on a tape or computer, then from being told about it. It seems obvious that people learn in different ways but too often golf instructors present their instruction in a “one size fits all” manner.

3) They accurately assess what the client is able to take in.

Like changing someone’s self – defeating thinking in therapy, changing muscle memory in someone’s golf swing is difficult and has to be done with great patience and reasonable expectations. When making his first major swing change in 1998, Tiger Woods reportedly hit 1100 balls per day, most of them under the corrective guidance of a skilled coach. When amateurs like me take a lesson, we might hit a bucket or two of balls and then take a swing change to the course, only to become frustrated when the results are inconsistent. Golf instructors often give their amateur students too much information, too many ideas, too many corrections, instead of making one clear change at the time.

Recently, I was taking a lesson from a terrific teacher who was working with my tendency to pull the ball. He suggested that I experiment with feeling that my body was moving from “low to high” in the downswing and follow through in order to keep myself more behind the ball. It felt strange, but I worked on this the entire hour. He said very little about anything else. He told me not to worry about hitting the ball thin or even if I found myself hitting fades. I gradually began to get this feeling more ingrained and stopped pulling the ball.

In the stall next to us, however, was another instructor working with a high-handicap student. The instructor was talking incessantly. He was telling the person all about the golf swing, about swing planes, weight shifts, and balance. The student was clearly overwhelmed. Golf instructors need to learn that sometimes “less is more.”

4) They provide a clear and explicit “treatment” plan.

Whether they’re driving a car, doing therapy, or trying to change their golf swing people like to know where they’re going. Golf instruction often fails when it is presented in a scattergun fashion, with no systematic game plan. Further, too often the golf coach doesn’t remember what the student was working on in the previous session and reinvents the wheel each time. Let’s face it – there is always something wrong with my golf swing. At any given time a teacher could look at my swing and point out several problems. However, a good teacher has a plan, an intuitive and logical strategy for helping me improve over time.

I used to see a teacher who knew a lot about the golf swing but each time I saw him, it was clear that he had no memory of what we’d worked on two weeks before. He would look at my swing and whatever occurred to him first was what we would work on. It was always something important, but I rarely had a sense that we were building a swing, that there was a method to this madness. Students feel comforted and inspired when they know where they’re going and when they feel that their instructor has a plan for getting there.

As in psychotherapy, the primary mistake the golf teachers make is putting their own theories ahead of figuring out what the student or client needs. I know from both ends of the relationship that there is a natural inclination in helpers to feel insecure about their expertise and authority. In response to this, the process becomes subtly focused on demonstrating what the teacher knows rather than what the student needs. From the point of view of the student, it’s easy when they are suffering – whether in life or on the links – and put themselves into the care of a professional. Invariably, they blame themselves if they don’t make progress. Unfortunately, often the problem lies with the professional. Sometimes the professional needs their help in getting on track.

Here are some ways to become a better teacher:


1) Ask your students to try to tell you how he or she learns. Coax them to be as explicit as possible. For example, have them tell you if they prefer technical details or simply a few images. Such minimal information will inform you how best to work with that particular student.

2)   If you sense the student is not finding a lesson helpful, acknowledge that fact in a way that includes your own possible culpability and ask if he or she would like you to try to combat the problem from a different angle because this one isn’t working.

3)   Tell them they may or may not get better right away after one or two lessons, but that they should know whether or not there is a good fit between the two of you. If not, don’t hesitate to recommend another instructor who might be a better fit.

4) Ask them to tell you what they like about your style and what is most effective in getting through to them. This also provides reinforcement about how they learn best.

5) Remind them that they can’t blame the instruction if they don’t practice or play much and are not getting better!

There are a lot of good golf instructors out there, and I’ve seen my share of them. They are worth their weight in gold. Ultimately it’s the student’s responsibility to take control of his or her learning. And it’s the teacher’s job to figure out how best to make that happen.



Wednesday, March 22, 2017

What Bobby Jones Had to Say Still Applies Today

Either Bobby Jones was ahead of his time or this philosophy got lost as the years went by.


I read a lot of the writings and thoughts of the greats of the past because I believe their message is still effective today and that the future of golf instruction is in learning to teach better.  Not in learning more "what to teach."  It appears that Bobby Jones knew over 70 years ago something that is now being learned, or relearned about how people of all ages learn to swing the golf club.  The science behind human learning is slowly seeping into golf instruction.

They learn primarily with their eyes and not their ears! 

There are sub-groups under that -  visual, auditory, read-write, and kinesthetic, but we primarily learn with our eyes.

Without getting too deep into the rabbit hole of neuroscience, the Holonomic brain theory supports that people learn motor skills not by linking a progression of positions together like line-by-line computer code, but instead by storing the entire movement as a neural 3-D hologram.  In other words they learn from watching.  

It appears that Stewart Maiden and Bobby Jones understood this.
Bobby wasn't a big proponent of teaching the golf swing.  Bobby learned the game by playing and observing the pro at his club, Stewart Maiden.  Maiden did not spend time on the practice tee giving Bobby swing instruction.  In fact, Bobby claimed that, to the best of his knowledge, Maiden never allowed himself to be drawn into a discussion about the golf swing.  To Stewart Maiden, golf was all about striking the wee ball.  Bobby might have been convinced to write about the swing, but I suspect he did so with mixed emotions.  He was not a man who believed in playing the game in a mechanical way.  He was not a fan of what he called, "rigid adherence to prescribed routine," in the teaching and learning of the golf swing. 
Bobby wrote: "Even if a person may not have begun to play golf at an early age, I believe that he may gain much by emphasizing naturalness in his learning processes. I think he has the right to convince himself that an effective golf swing can be made without rigid adherence to a prescribed routine and that there is room for differences in physical structure and capabilities. No matter how nearly equal in performance the top-rank players may be, yet they are as recognizable by their swings as by their faces.
"What the average golfer needs more than fine spun theories," Bobby wrote, "is something that will give him a clearer conception of what he should try to do with the clubhead... When we speak of sound method or good form, we mean nothing more than that the possessor of either has simplified his swing to the point where errors are less likely to creep in and he is able consistently to bring his club against the ball in the correct hitting position."



Tuesday, March 21, 2017

If You are Considering Taking Golf Lessons.....


Finding a Good Instructor/Coach


The major reason it is difficult to find good golf instruction today is that instructors/coaches are not ranked by results.  The PGA, Golf Digest, no one does this.  What we need is an “Angie’s List” for golf professionals.  This may be why only 2 out of 17 golfers take lessons.  I’m sure it is at least a factor.

At this point word-of-mouth is all we have.  If you are thinking of taking lessons, you need to do some research before you pay your hard earned money to someone.  The good ones will have no problem with this.  If they are offended by your questions then move on.  You would be wasting your money with them anyway.

Here are a few points to consider before signing up with someone:

  • If they try to sell you a package up front there is a problem.  If they haven’t spent any time with someone how can they possibly have any idea how many lessons you will need.  Packages are not bad unless you are being asked to sign up for one initially.


  • If they do split screen video comparing your swing to some tour player and proceed to point out how many things are wrong in your swing you need to ask for your money back.  This is what is generally referred to as “Let me show you how many ways your swing sucks” school of instruction.


  • The real red flag is do they teach a method?  Every instructor should have a method of teaching but should never teach a method.  It’s like saying “One size fits all”.  No method fits everyone.  People and golf swings are individual.
  • They spend a lot of time talking about how much they know and how good a player they are.


  • They don’t spend any time asking about your goals, medical problems, and swing thoughts.

Here is some things you can expect from a good instructor/coach:


  • Introduction. Students are often intimidated by teaching professionals, so he or she will try setting the student at ease and developing a rapport prior to the session. This leads to more effective communication between the teacher and the student.


  • They will want background information. This information includes: Previous golf and sports history; previous injury history; ask about physical limitations; occupation; previous instruction history; goals for golf.


  • They will want specific golf information. This includes: examination of the golfer's equipment; ball flight characteristics; determining how far the golfer hits each club; strengths and weaknesses in the various aspects of golf; practice habits; motivation for playing golf (i.e., competition vs. hobby vs. spouse activity, etc.); motivation for taking golf lessons.


  • A good instructor will form a personal relationship with you and be personally interested in your success.
  • There is even a trend now among the good one ones to offer monthly and yearly rates for unlimited help since people learn more effectively in frequent, short sessions.


The real art of instruction is figuring out what is integral to each players swing and knowing that you should not try to change that.  You have to work around it and help them become the best they can be with the fundamental swing they have.  If you know someone who does this, please let me know.  I want to promote them to everyone.  I already have my list of teachers.

There is good news though.  There is a growing number of instructors out there that will help you simplify what you need to do and will help you maximize your swing and ability – not remake your swing in their image of what they think it should like.  It’s just difficult to find them because they don’t get much publicity.

Word of Caution


One word of caution – if you try to go it alone, keep this in mind that it is going to be incredibly difficult .  If you google golf instruction, golf tips, how to fix a slice, etc. you will get a huge selection.  One reason for this is that these people are in it for the money and not to primarily concerned with helping golfers.  You are bombarded by emails and infomercials telling you that if you buy this DVD or training aid, this book, etc. your game will dramatically improve and each one is telling you a different secret.  They have tour players and ex-tour players swearing its some type of breakthrough.  I hate to tell you, but virtually all of them are all scams.  Nobody has the secret because there is no secret.  They are simply trying to make money off you regardless of what they tell you in their video.  Anyone that appears on the first page of google results has an ulterior motive or they wouldn’t go to that much trouble to get that highly ranked.

If you have questions or would like to get in touch with me just leave a comment.


Wednesday, March 15, 2017

Golf Instruction Has Become Too Complex


In the battle of simplicity vs. complexity, simplicity wins, every time. We gravitate toward products and services that eliminate complexity from our lives, and we rail against the things that complicate matters and make us feel stupid.

Back in the days of the three-martini lunch, golf instruction was simple and appealing. Back then 90% of the clubs were private and as a country club member you had a pro at your disposal. He’d work with you on the driving range, play with you, coach you to get better, and monitor your progress.

It was a personalized, one-on-one experience.

No two lessons were the same. He worked with the swing you had, and helped you build the skills you needed to score well on the golf course. Accountability was built in… You’d practice because you knew the pro was keeping an eye on your progress.

But those days are gone.

Today, less than 5% of all golfers have a relationship with a golf pro. Surveys have shown that the number of golfers that think lessons could help them is around 15 out of 20.  The interesting thing is that only about 2 out every 17 are taking lessons.  Maybe we should think about why that is…

Is it because most lessons are totally intimidating, especially for women. Is it because most instructors make them way too complex!  The most common response from golfers is that either they didn’t get better or their buddies that took lessons didn’t get better.

It is a rare instructor who sends the student off with fewer than five or six “things to work on.”  According to Phil Mickelson, even the tour gurus are often guilty of over-instruction. “Can’t you just give me one thing to work on?”

Often it’s a checklist of a dozen mechanical issues that the average guy can’t possibly grasp, much less incorporate into his game. The more technical the lesson is, the worse it gets.

Group lessons are often ineffective because a statement made in the group will be interpreted differently by each member of the group.  Most golf schools are especially ineffective because the student is taught by several different instructors, each giving them different things to work on.  Common complaints include: “I came back worse than when I started.” “It was just way too technical.” “He didn’t give me anything positive, it was all about what I was doing wrong.”

Much of today’s technology only seems to help the most analytical, I want to know it all type learners; Maybe one half of one percent of the golfing population. And yet, instructors routinely use it to analyze every position and point out every flaw.

More often than not, it’s just confusing and demoralizing for the student.

In an issue of Golf Digest, Jim Flick, one of the top five teachers of all time, wrote an article that sums up the problem with modern golf instruction:

“A lot of today’s teachers are enamored with what works for the tour pros, and they give the same information to their higher-handicap students… In general, trying to swing like most of today’s tour pros will make the average golfer – say a 5 handicap or higher, – only worse.”

Rather than working with the student’s natural swing, today’s teachers tell everyone to emulate or copy whatever tour player swing is in favor at the time..

They bottom line is that if the golf industry is going to turn things around, the methods of instruction HAVE to change.  We’ve got to make it less complex, enjoyable and fun.  The focus needs to be on the most effective ways people actually learn.  For instance people tend to respond much more favorably to train instead of practice.  We practice law and medicine, but we should train to improve our golf.  Training involves trying and learning from your successes or failures.  Training also involves coaching instead of teaching.

That is my take on things from The Golf Cave for today.  You can see more of my thoughts on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/samadams46 or Twitter at https://twitter.com/SamAdam5346